FBI takes another gratuitous, desperate swipe at Maher Arar’s reputation
In what appears to have been a last ditch effort to make some use of Guantanamo trials that will almost certainly be shut down within the first few days of an Obama presidency, and in a seemingly desperate attempt to detract attention from, or somehow justify, the shameful legacy of lawlessness and torture that has marred the credibility of American and Canadian law enforcement and security agencies since 9/11, the FBI has taken another gratuitous swipe at Maher Arar’s reputation.
Today, at a pre-trial hearing for Omar Khadr in Guantanamo Bay, FBI interrogator Robert Fuller testified that in October 2002, a then just turned 16 year-old Omar Khadr, while incarcerated at the American’s military base in Bagram, Afghanistan, said that he had seen Arar in Afghanistan, an allegation Arar has long denied.
Never mind that nothing that anyone has said to interrogators at the Bagram air force base, where so much prisoner abuse, torture and even prisoner deaths have been documented, can be considered remotely reliable. As Michelle Shephard, Toronto Star journalist and author of Guantanamo’s Child: The Untold Story of Omar Khadr notes, some of Bagram’s interrogators were later convicted of killing an innocent Afghan citizen during an interrogation there.
And never mind that Khadr has said that he repeatedly lied to interrogators in order to improve his detention conditions, especially when interrogators kept saying that if only he cooperated, he’d be sent home.
The fact is that Maher Arar has been exonerated.
First, by an exhaustive four-year long public inquiry in Canada which concluded that Canadian agencies had no evidence of wrongdoing by Arar, and that the U.S. “very likely” based their decision to send him to torture in Syria on erroneous Canadian information.
Then, by the Harper government itself, which, before settling Arar’s law suit, sent then-public safety minister Stockwell Day to the U.S to see the American file on Arar.
Day returned to say there was nothing there that would justify keeping Arar on a watchlist, and within weeks Prime Minister Harper was on live television issuing an official, and long-overdue, public apology on behalf of the government to Arar and his family.
Not much later, Arar and his family were deservedly financially compensated for Canada’s role in what happened to him.
Quite simply, the information put forth today, coming from an agency under fire for its legacy of complicity in torture, cannot be trusted.
Maher Arar and his family have endured enough.
It is the record of the FBI, CIA, RCMP, CSIS and other security agencies that must come under scrutiny now — not Maher Arar’s.
Tags: FBI, Guantanamo, Maher Arar, Omar Khadr, smear
January 20th, 2009 at 2:35 pm
Khadr’s CHIEF and first INTERROGATOR at Bagram was Sgt. Joshua Claus, who was court-martialled after an innocent Afghan prisoner was beaten to death.
The man Khadr’s chief interrogator’s team tortured to death was DILAWAR, a 22 year-old innocent Afghanistan taxi driver.
His abuse and death under torture is described in the Oscar winning DOCUMENTARY “Taxi to the Dark Side”, by American filmmaker Alex Gibney.
This is how they “got started” with Khadr…
References
Edmonton Sun:
http://www.edmontonsun.com/News/Canada/2008/03/18/5041486.html
http://jurist.law.pitt.edu/paperchase/2008/03/guantanamo-detainee-khadr-accuses-us.php
January 22nd, 2009 at 4:08 pm
Letter: This story sounds like complete baloney to me. For starters, the testimony comes from torture: with torture, victims say whatever they think is wanted by their torturers. The timing is very suspicious – the day before Obama, who says he will close Guantanamo, is inaugurated, and during the lawsuit in US courts challenging Mr. Arar’s rendition to Syria by the U.S. government.
Surely Mr Arar and his family have suffered enough. He has been proven innocent by a Canadian inquiry. It is time to allow Maher and Monia to recover from their ordeal, get on with their lives, and bring up their family in peace.